Brooks Glycerin vs. Asics Gel Nimbus

Different kinds of running shoes can look incredibly similar, even down to the cost of the shoes. What do you do if the shoes have the same drop, design, or support?

Often times, purchasing a brand new pair of running shoes can be overwhelming and intimidating as it is, so how do you choose between two pairs that may seem extremely similar in specs and design?


In general, the Brooks Glycerin features a wider toe box with a roomier, more cushioned fit, the ASICS Gel-Nimbus offers a snug fit from the heel through the midfoot 

The Brooks Glycerin features the unique Brooks’ DNA Loft foam cushioning, while the ASICS includes a gel material in its midsole foam.

The ASICS shoe also includes a gender-specific TRUSSTIC support device, which provides extra support and creates a smooth transition from heel to toe.

Key Takeaways

  • Brooks and ASICS are two popular running shoe brands with well-cushioned and comfortable shoes.
  • The Brooks Glycerin and ASICS Gel-Nimbus are both priced higher than typical running shoes and offer similar features with some notable differences.
  • The Glycerin has a wider toe box and uses DNA Loft foam for cushioning, while the Gel-Nimbus is more snug and incorporates a gel material and gender-specific TRUSSTIC device.

Brooks Glycerin vs. Asics Gel Nimbus 

As a running shoe enthusiast, I am always on the lookout for the most comfortable and well-cushioned shoes on the market. Today, I will be comparing two popular running shoe brands, Brooks and ASICS, and their most plush running shoes, the Brooks Glycerin and ASICS Gel-Nimbus.

Both shoes are priced higher than your typical running shoe, but promise to provide maximum comfort and support during your runs.

While both shoes have similar features, there are some notable differences between them. The Glycerin has a wider toe box and roomier fit, while the Gel-Nimbus is more snug in the midfoot through the heel.

The Glycerin uses Brooks' DNA Loft foam for cushioning, while the Gel-Nimbus incorporates a gel material in its midsole foam. Additionally, the Gel-Nimbus includes a gender-specific TRUSSTIC device for extra support and a smooth heel-to-toe transition.

Brooks Glycerin vs. ASICS Gel Nimbus: This article will help you to narrow your search to the style of shoe you should buy and the features of each pair...

Upper Comparison: 

ASICS Gel-Nimbus

I tried the ASICS Gel-Nimbus 25 and was impressed with its multi-directional mesh upper. The upper hugged my foot and felt durable enough to withstand long runs. The spacious toe box provided enough room for my toes to splay naturally.

The tongue on the Gel-Nimbus 25 was plush with thick padding, and the tongue's gussets provided an excellent midfoot lockdown without sacrificing any of the shoe’s flexibility. The heel collar also featured plush padding, which worked well with the medium stiffness heel counter. I felt like it wrapped around my Achilles tendon and felt secure throughout the gait cycle.

Brooks Glycerin

The Brooks Glycerin 20 had a multi-layered, seamless, one-piece mesh upper that molded to my foot. Brooks used their 3D Fit Print technology for the upper, which provided structure and stretch to the shoe in different zones. This increased the flexibility of the shoe, making it lighter and more breathable.

I found that there was plenty of space in the toe box for my toes to splay, while my midfoot and heel had a secure, locked-in feeling. The 3D Fit print overlays were minimal and did not cause any irritation or discomfort while I ran.

Brooks Glycerin 19

The heel counter was rigid and kept my heel locked in, while the heel collar was generously padded for extra comfort. One of my favorite features was the gusseted tongue, which was made from stretchy polyester and helped to lock the midfoot down. This extra layer of material breathed well and did not create any hot spots while running.

The tongue itself was plush and heavily padded, but it was soft and did not create pressure points on the bridge of my foot. I loved the tubular laces as they were flexible and had enough stretch to get the perfect fit without changing the lockdown of the upper. I found that the foot lockdown was so secure that I did not have to do heel lock lacing!


Midsole

Brooks Glycerin

I have found that the midsole of the Brooks Glycerin 20 provides a luxurious underfoot feel. Brooks has added more DNA Loft foam to the midsole, which gives the shoe a soft landing feel without feeling mushy or like you're sinking into the shoe.

Despite the extra cushioning, the shoe doesn't feel bulky. Runners will experience a smooth ride with some responsiveness and bounce. The shoe is versatile and suitable for long runs as well as speedwork, thanks to the cushioning that absorbs more shock.

ASICS Gel-Nimbus

The ASICS Gel-Nimbus 25 is a max-cushioning shoe that doesn't have an excessive stack height. The men's shoe has a stack height of 25mm/15mm—heel-to-toe, while the women's shoe is 27mm/14mm.

This shoe features FlyteFoam Propel technology and FlyteFoam cushioning, as well as a gel unit in the heel. The gel unit helps to absorb impact and distribute it evenly throughout the shoe, while the dual layers of foam provide a smooth, responsive, and comfortable underfoot feel.

ASICS Gel Nimbus

As soon as I stepped into the ASICS Gel-Nimbus 25, I noticed how soft the heel of the shoe is and how it compresses. This softer gel unit is particularly beneficial for heel strikers, as it makes landings easier and softer. Runners will find that it helps the foot to roll smoothly in the transition.

ASICS Gel Nimbus - tread

Outsole

Brooks Glycerin

The Brooks Glycerin 20 features a segmented outsole made of soft blown rubber. The forefoot has flex grooves to enhance flexibility, and a guidance line runs along the lateral side of the shoe. The lateral side of the shoe has some exposed midsole, and a strip of rubber extends from the heel up to the forefoot to provide smoother transitions and midfoot stability.

The use of soft blown rubber in the outsole provides excellent grip and traction, but it may wear down faster than other materials.

Brooks Glycerin 19 - heel

ASICS Gel-Nimbus

The outsole of the ASICS Gel-Nimbus 25 has been updated with a similar geometry to its predecessor. It is made of two types of rubber, ASICS high abrasion rubber (AHAR) in the forefoot, and more durable AHAR+ rubber in the heel.

The outsole has exposed midsole foam channels, and the rubber lugs are now arranged sideways to provide a softer, more flexible ride. The gender-specific TRUSSTIC device provides extra support and helps to generate smooth transitions.

ASICS Gel Nimbus - Support

Other Features

Price

The Brooks Glycerin 20 and ASICS Gel-Nimbus 25 both have a price of $150.00 at the time of writing. Although this price may be higher than other running shoes, both shoes are considered max-cushioning shoes designed to reduce the risk of injury and provide a comfortable ride.

Stiffness/Flex

The Glycerin 20 is not a very flexible shoe, but it is not stiff either. It is responsive and provides a slightly springy sensation. The shoe has inherent stability due to its wider platform, flared design of the midsole and outsole.

On the other hand, the ASICS Gel-Nimbus 25 is surprisingly flexible, and runners will find the shoe to be both responsive and soft. However, runners may feel a slight sensation of the road beneath their feet. The Trusstic system provides support but is not as aggressive as stability shoes like the Gel-Kayano.

Drop

Both the Glycerin 20 and ASICS Gel-Nimbus 25 have a 10 mm heel-to-toe drop, which is a common heel-to-toe drop in running shoes. However, the women's model of the ASICS Gel-Nimbus 25 features a drop of 13 mm. This higher heel-to-toe drop is to accommodate for the gender-specific differences of women's feet, gait pattern, weight, and lower-limb biomechanics.

Weight

The weight difference between the Glycerin 20 and the ASICS Gel-Nimbus 25 is negligible. The men's Glycerin 20 shoe weighs 10.2 oz—289.2 grams, and the women's shoe weighs 9.0 oz—255.1 grams. The men's Gel-Nimbus weighs 10.9 oz—310 grams, and the women's shoe weighs 9.2 oz—260 grams. Despite being slightly heavier shoes, runners will find that they do not feel heavy on their feet when running in them.

Summary

As a runner, choosing the right shoes is crucial to ensure maximum comfort and performance. The Brooks Glycerin 20 and the ASICS Gel-Nimbus 25 are two popular options that offer excellent cushioning and shock-absorption. The ASICS Gel-Nimbus is a good choice for runners who need more heel cushion and stability, thanks to its gel unit and TRUSSTIC device. Additionally, it offers gender-specific features that may benefit female runners. On the other hand, the Brooks Glycerin is a great option for runners who prefer a roomier fit and wider toe box, without sacrificing responsiveness. Ultimately, the choice between these two shoes depends on individual preferences and needs.

ASICS Gel Nimbus - uppers


Brooks Glycerin 20

I recently had the opportunity to try out the Brooks Glycerin 20 running shoes, and I must say, I was impressed with their performance. These shoes are designed for neutral runners who are looking for a comfortable and supportive shoe for their daily runs.

Here are some of the key features of the Brooks Glycerin 20:

  • DNA LOFT cushioning: This technology provides a soft and comfortable ride, while still maintaining responsiveness and durability.
  • 3D Fit Print upper: The upper is designed to be breathable and flexible, while still providing a secure and comfortable fit.
  • OrthoLite sockliner: This sockliner provides additional cushioning and moisture management, helping to keep your feet dry and comfortable.
  • Rubber outsole: The outsole is designed to provide traction and durability on a variety of surfaces.

Overall, I found the Brooks Glycerin 20 to be a great option for runners who are looking for a comfortable and supportive shoe for their daily runs. The cushioning and fit are both excellent, and the shoe provides a smooth and responsive ride. If you're in the market for a new pair of running shoes, I would definitely recommend giving the Brooks Glycerin 20 a try.

Brooks Men's Glycerin 20 Neutral Running Shoe - Black/White/Alloy - 10 Wide
1,871 Reviews
Brooks Men's Glycerin 20 Neutral Running Shoe - Black/White/Alloy - 10 Wide
  • LIGHT SNEAKS: Run for miles without tiring your feet wearing the Brooks Glycerin 20 Sneakers featuring a round toe silhouette along with a redesigned midsole and outsole with a widened platform for smooth and easy transitions
  • QUALITY BUILD: Sneaks feature a plush and breathable engineered textile and synthetic upper, a comfy textile lining and insole, and a nitrogen-infused DNA LOFT v3 midsole for lightweight performance and responsive rebound
  • LACE-UP CLOSURE: Easy to pull on and off, our Brooks Glycerin 20 sneakers showcase a traditional lace-up closure with an improved fit to secure your foot perfectly in place
  • IDEAL TRACTION: Built with our durable and flexible rubber outsole that provides durable traction and grip, letting you move confidently through both dry and wet conditions
  • NEUTRAL HUES: These comfy trail-running shoes are available in multiple men’s sizes with 4 neutral color options that will blend in with the trail and give your confidence a boost

ASICS GEL-Nimbus 25

I recently had the opportunity to try out the ASICS GEL-Nimbus 25, and I must say, I was impressed. This shoe is designed with the runner in mind, offering both comfort and support.

The GEL-Nimbus 25 features ASICS' signature GEL cushioning technology, which provides excellent shock absorption and helps to reduce the impact on your joints. The shoe also has a FlyteFoam midsole, which is lightweight and provides a responsive feel.

One thing I particularly liked about the GEL-Nimbus 25 is the breathable upper. It kept my feet cool and dry, even during longer runs. The shoe also has a spacious toe box, which allowed my toes to splay out naturally.

Overall, the ASICS GEL-Nimbus 25 is a great option for runners looking for a comfortable and supportive shoe.

Sale
ASICS Men's Gel-Nimbus 25 Running Shoes, 9, Sheet Rock/Indigo Blue
1,317 Reviews
ASICS Men's Gel-Nimbus 25 Running Shoes, 9, Sheet Rock/Indigo Blue
  • Engineered knit upper: Wraps the foot with a soft feel while improving breathability
  • At least 75% of the shoe's main upper material is made with recycled content to reduce waste and carbon emissions:
  • The sockliner is produced with the solution dyeing process that reduces water usage by approximately 33% and carbon emissions by approximately 45% compared to the conventional dyeing technology:
  • PureGEL technology: Helps provide lightweight cushioning and softer landings
  • FF BLAST ECO PLUS technology: Cushioning creates a softer landing and a more responsive toe-off

Frequently Asked Questions

How do Brooks Glycerin and Asics Nimbus compare in terms of support and cushioning?

Both Brooks Glycerin and Asics Nimbus are highly cushioned running shoes that provide excellent support to the feet. However, Brooks Glycerin is known for its plush cushioning and comfortable fit, whereas Asics Nimbus is popular for its responsive cushioning and lightweight design.

Which shoe is better for long distance running, Brooks Glycerin or Asics Nimbus?

Both Brooks Glycerin and Asics Nimbus are great options for long distance running. However, Brooks Glycerin is preferred by many long distance runners due to its superior cushioning and comfortable fit.

What are the key differences between Brooks Glycerin 20 and Asics Gel-Nimbus?

Brooks Glycerin 20 and Asics Gel-Nimbus are both highly cushioned running shoes that provide excellent support to the feet. However, Brooks Glycerin 20 is known for its plush cushioning and comfortable fit, whereas Asics Gel-Nimbus is popular for its responsive cushioning and lightweight design.

Are there any notable differences in fit between Asics and Brooks shoes?

Yes, there are some notable differences in fit between Asics and Brooks shoes. Asics shoes tend to have a narrower fit, whereas Brooks shoes have a wider fit. It's important to try on both brands to see which one fits your feet better.

What are some similar shoes to Asics Gel-Nimbus in the Brooks lineup?

Some similar shoes to Asics Gel-Nimbus in the Brooks lineup include Brooks Glycerin, Brooks Ghost, and Brooks Levitate.

Which shoe is better for people with flat feet, Brooks Glycerin or Asics Nimbus?

Both Brooks Glycerin and Asics Nimbus are great options for people with flat feet. However, Brooks Glycerin is known for its superior cushioning and support, making it a great choice for those with flat feet.

Other Running Shoe Comparisons

Hi, Jeremy Here, 

I am the the guy behind Train for a 5K. On this site, I share everything that learned along my running journey. The content I create is the running training I wish I had before we started this journeyAbout Jeremy. 

I have run over 250 races including the California International Marathon, Clarksburg Country Run, and various other 5K & 10K races throughout the United States. I am a former Athletics department employee at University of the Pacific and Shoe Consultant with Dicks Sporting Goods

Last update on 2023-09-25 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API