Tread Labs vs Superfeet – How Do They Compare?

Updated On

Footwear today is made to support all sorts of daily activity – work, house work, playing with your kids or pets and of course includes fitness activities like running and hiking. However, sometimes you might need just a bit of extra support and stability and insoles are the perfect solution.  

Insoles are a great option because most are interchangeable meaning you can use the insole for all your shoes. You can use them in new sneakers, old sneakers, leisure shoes, work shoes and even shoes for a fancy night out. But, when it comes to athletic shoes insoles can make all the difference, especially for runners. Tread Labs and Superfeet are amongst the most popular on the market and consistently the best reviewed.

Company History Tread Labs & Superfeet:

-Tread Labs was born after founder Mark Paigen spent 20 years developing Chaco sandals to use while he was leading river trips in Colorado. He eventually sold that company and fully immersed himself in creating the perfect insole.

Paigen’s goal was to make the world’s most comfortable shoe, “I designed an insole concept that provides incredible comfort. An array of sizes and arch heights guarantees a perfect fit, and the insoles can be used in any kind of low-heeled shoe.”  

Tread Labs comes with a 30-day fit guarantee, as well as a life time guarantee against defects in workmanship and materials.

-Superfeet insoles have been designed by science and upgrades your 2-dimensional footwear to a more supportive 3 dimensions. They have earned over 40 U.S. and international patents. 

Superfeet focuses on extra support at the back of your foot as that is where most of your range of motion originates from. Superfeet comes with a limited warranty of 60 days and “provides its products “AS IS AND WITH ALL FAULTS”.”

Tread Labs Insoles

Tread Labs Stride Insoles – Orthotic Shoe Inserts Relieve Plantar Fasciitis – Treat Foot Pain – Firm Arch Support – Improve Comfort and Performance – M10-11.5 Low Arch

Tread Labs insoles are made with arch support in mind, it comes in four levels; x-high, high, medium and low as well as a deep heel to cushion your step. On the Tread Lab website is a “find your fit” quiz to help find the insole that is perfect for you.  

These insoles come specifically for golfing, hiking, cycling, running, skiing, and tennis but work well in any type of shoe. The extra cushion and support offered by Tread Labs can improve your stride, reduce shin splints and stress fractures as well as help you feel more aligned and supported.

The actual insole is made out of two parts, there is a 2mm top cover that is made from anti-microbial foam material that kills 99.9% of bacteria. Tread Labs are highly durable as they are made from polyurethane foam and low friction polyester.  

What I Like:

The best thing about these insoles is the reusable and easily replaceable top covers that attach with Velcro. Tread Labs are excellent for several specific foot complications like plantar fasciitis, flat feet, high arches, stress fractures, runners knee and over pronation.

These insoles are firm but flexible, supportive and the deep heel is for maximum shock absorption. The top cover is made from low friction material that will keep your feet dry and reduce your risk of blisters. Made from an open cell polyurethane foam, these insoles provide comfort 5x longer than other insoles.

Tread Lab Insoles come with a 30-day fit guarantee. They also come with a lifetime guarantee of the arch support, if this part becomes cracked, broken or lose their shape – you can send them back to Tread Labs and they will replace them free of charge. The top covers are easily replaceable for $15.

Tread Labs - Top Cover Replacements
These replacement top covers are the comfort layer for Stride insoles. They attach with low profile hook and loop. Replace your top covers when necessary or get a different pair to enable your insoles to fit perfectly in different shoes
Tread labs insoles

Tread Labs comes with several different versions of insoles. There is the Stride Short which is best suited for shoes that have insoles that can’t be removed and are perfect for dress shoes and flats.

There is the Stride Thin that works best with shoes that have removable insoles like sports shoes like cleats. The most popular of their insoles with the most reviews is Stride which is perfect for running shoes and hiking boots.  What makes these insoles so popular is the extra support and comfort they provide as well as how versatile they are. Tread labs are recommended for those who have flat feet

Superfeet Insoles

Superfeet GREEN Full Length Insole, Green, Large E: 10.5 - 12 US Womens / 9.5 - 11 US Mens

The SuperFeet insoles offer extra support and responsiveness as well as stabilization of the foot. They help to alleviate pain and foot fatigue and they help protect your feet and ankles as well as your back and spine caused by the high impact running has on your body. They can also help correct your stride which will relieve the strain on your legs, hips and back.

The SuperFeet insole is made from a high density, closed cell foam making the insole firm and highly supportive. The insole will run the entire length of your shoe and is created from Aerospring synch making it very light, it also has a deep and wide heel cup for added support and maximum shock absorption. This insole will replace the entire original insole and is made from a 3d printed smart cap.

What I Like:

Superfeet makes insoles for heaps of different activities, from just daily activity to intense workouts, grueling hikes or for a night out on the town in your highest heels, there is an insole for everything. Each insole focuses on extra stabilization and support of the heel because that is where all of your range of motion comes from.

Superfeet makes many different insoles for any type of fit you are looking for.

They make insoles for everyday use, high heels, running, trailblazing, hockey, trophy, guide, heritage, “me”, flex, easyfit and custom. Most superfeet insoles come specifically made for male and female wearers. Amongst their most popular are the men’s and women’s EVERYDAY Slimfit, the heritage REDhot, and the FLEX.  These are so popular because they work for everyone and everything. They help relieve pain in the foot as well as the rest of the body.

Conclusion: Which is the Better Fit?

Tread Labs Review:

  • Made in 2 parts - the top cover is cheap and easy to replace, the arch support is guaranteed for life
  • Comes in multiple arch heights
  • Deep heel cup for ultimate shock absorption
  • Made from an open cell polyurethane foam
  • Firm but flexible
Stride Semi-Custom Insoles for Men and Women – Relieve and Prevent The Pain of Plantar Fasciitis – 4 Distinct Arch Heights for Flat Feet, High Arches and Everything in Between
115 Reviews
Stride Semi-Custom Insoles for Men and Women – Relieve and Prevent The Pain of Plantar Fasciitis – 4 Distinct Arch Heights for Flat Feet, High Arches and Everything in Between
  • FIRM SUPPORT CURES PAIN FAST. Our first gen pain relief insoles offer the firm support necessary to improve your alignment and ease your pain. Don’t bother with soft foam inserts that do not have the strong support necessary for relief. Improve your comfort during the day and have more energy in the evening with the strong arch support of Stride insoles.
  • LIMIT PRONATION TO CURE THE PAIN OF PLANTAR FASCIITIS. Effective arch support limits pronation, decreasing the strain on your plantar fascia. This cures your pain at the root cause and is the key for long lasting relief. Eliminate your foot pain from the first steps of the day and enjoy more energy in the evening.
  • OUR ARCHES FIT YOUR ARCHES. The arches of your feet aren’t generic. They’re yours alone. Don’t settle for generic inserts made for the masses. Fit them with orthotic insoles that match your arch height and improve your alignment. Tread Labs makes 4 arch heights for men and women to perfectly support flat feet (fallen arches), extra high arches and everything in between.

Super Feet Review:

  • Replaces the entire insole of your shoe
  • 60-day limited warranty
  • Made from a high density, closed cell foam
  • Firm and supportive
  • Deep heel cup for maximum shock absorption
Superfeet Green Premium-U Insole, 9.5-11 Men / 10.5-12 Women
7,647 Reviews
Superfeet Green Premium-U Insole, 9.5-11 Men / 10.5-12 Women
  • DEEP HEEL CUP - Superfeets widest and deepest heel cup that offers maximum support and positions the soft tissue to help with natural shock absorption
  • ODOR-CONTROL COATING - All natural coating that eliminates odor-causing bacteria Closed-cell foam supports and cushions the foot for long lasting comfort

Depending on what type of support you are looking for and what type of activity you are doing, insoles are a functional option. Tread Labs and Super Feet have consistently been the highest rated and the most reviewed semi-custom orthotic insoles.

Although there are some differences, both of these insoles can help relieve pain – especially due to plantar fasciitis. They will also help protect your joints and ligaments from the high impact running and other intensive fitness regimes have on your body.

Last update on 2020-08-06 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API