Superfeet Black vs Carbon – Differences Explained

Updated On

Throughout your running, your training, and your racing, there is always going to be one thing that might throw off your running.

Whether it is something with your diet or your physical body something is bound to happen at some point during your entire running career. 

If something happens physically with your body, whether you get injured or not, it is important to know what you can do to keep your body healthy.

One way that you can keep your body healthy is through having the proper equipment that works well with your body. 

If you struggle with ankle, plantar fasciitis, or achilles tendonitis issues, one way you can help your body to recover or even prevent it all is by finding great running shoe insoles that work well for your body and your feet!

Two running shoe insole options are Superfeet Black and Carbon.

This article will help you to know if these brands of running shoe insoles are right for your body, your feet, and your training.

Superfeet Carbon - Best Choice

#1
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens

Wide Insole

Sturdy Heel Cup

Additional Padding in the Midfoot and Forefoot


5 of 5 Stars

What can insoles help you with?

Running shoe insoles can help in preventing and recovering a multitude of injuries. How do they do that? 

Many people have a natural pronation in their step; this can cause your feet to tilt slightly inward, especially if you wear shoes that do not have a good arch in them. 

This can cause extreme soreness and exhaustion on your ankles which could potentially lead to straining the muscles or tendons in your ankles and potentially lead to injury.

Insoles can also help keep away plantar fasciitis by supporting your arches whether they are too high or too flat.

Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens
Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens
Prime
Rating
-
Reviews
1,451 Reviews
-
Price
Price not available
$54.93
Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Prime
Rating
Reviews
1,451 Reviews
Price
Price not available
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens
Prime
Rating
-
Reviews
-
Price
$54.93

The Biggest Differences:

Superfeet Carbon are the thinner of the two options. Both last about 12 months or 500 miles.

The Carbon also offers a slightly wider insole and a structured/sturdy heel cup is that helps support the foot. Superfeet Black offers a higher ability to repel odor.

Superfeet Black:  Review

The Superfeet Black running insoles are incredible thin running shoe insole with six amazing features that will help to support your stride throughout all of your runs.

Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens

To begin with, they have a super durable construction; the inserts can last for up to twelve months or 500 miles while keeping their shape, whichever mile stone comes first!

The Superfeet Black have a great, low profile shape that offers incredible support and stabilization to your feet which can help to reduce the stress on your feet, ankles, and knees. 

Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens

Two integral parts of the sleek shape of these insole inserts are the heel cup and the stabilizer cap. 

The accommodating heel cup helps to stabilize the heel offering support to your ankle all the way up your leg.

The stabilizer cap provides structure behind your foot to ensure there is flexible support throughout the insole in a way that minimizes the volume of the insole insert. 

Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens

To top it all off, the Superfeet Black insoles have a natural coating surrounding the insole insert that helps to eliminate odor causing bacteria so your insoles can stay fresh throughout the time you have them.

Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
1,451 Reviews
Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
  • FIT PROFILE: Low volume / Low profile (Volume refers to the amount of space the insole will take up in your shoe. Profile is how much shape you can expect to feel under your foot)
  • STABILIZER CAP: the reinforced rearfoot of the cap provides structure and support for our most flexible, low-volume insole
  • HEEL CUP: features the most accommodating heel cup and can help stabilize and support the foot
  • SUPERFEET SHAPE: the flexible, low-profile shape helps stabilize and support the foot, which can help reduce stress on feet, ankles and knees
  • HIGH-DENSITY FOAM LAYER: closed-cell foam supports and cushions the foot for long-lasting comfort

Superfeet Carbon: Review

The Superfeet Carbon insole inserts are the thinnest shoe insole inserts made by Superfeet and have a variety of incredible features to help support you and your body.

They have the same Superfeet construction that helps the inserts to last up to twelve months or 500 miles while maintaining their superior shape.

The Carbon low profile shape helps to support your feet, ankles, and knees with four awesome features! 

Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens

The first feature to note is the Carbon Fiber Stabilizer Cap; this supports the rearfoot by providing stability to the foam layer, reinforced by EVOLyte which is Superfeet’s propriety carbon fiber and polymer blend. 

The next feature is beveled foam edge along the insert which helps to improve the fit in tighter fitting footwear. The final two features are the forefoot and heel cup.

Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens

The forefoot is slightly wider than the standard inserts as to accommodate for a wider range of footwear while the heel cup is structured to help stabilize and support the foot while positioning the heel to absorb as much impact as possible.

The final two features of the Superfeet Carbon insole inserts work to keep your insoles and feet as fresh as possible.

These insoles have foam perforations under the midfoot and forefoot that help to reduce the weight and improve the breathability as well as a natural odor controlling coating that helps to eliminate odor causing bacteria. 

Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens

If you are going to be moving your insoles from one pair of shoes to another for work then training, I would get the Carbon insoles for the wider toe box.

However, if these insoles would live only in your running shoes, I would get the Superfeet Black.

Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens
  • FIT PROFILE: Low volume / Low profile (Volume refers to the amount of space the insole will take up in your shoe. Profile is how much shape you can expect to feel under your foot)
  • CARBON FIBER STABILIZER CAP: the stabilizer cap is reinforced with EVOLYTE, a proprietary carbon fiber & polymer blend, to provide structure and support
  • LOW-PROFILE DESIGN: the thinnest Superfeet insole
  • HEEL CUP: the structured heel cup helps stabilize and support the foot and positions the heel to naturally absorb impact
  • SUPERFEET SHAPE: the low-profile shape helps stabilize and support the foot, which can help reduce stress on feet, ankles and knees
Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens
Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens
Prime
Rating
-
Reviews
1,451 Reviews
-
Price
Price not available
$54.93
Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet BLACK, Thin Insoles for Orthotic Support in Tight Shoes, Dress and Athletic Footwear, Unisex, Black, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Prime
Rating
Reviews
1,451 Reviews
Price
Price not available
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Medium/D: 8.5-10 Wmns/7.5-9 Mens
Prime
Rating
-
Reviews
-
Price
$54.93

Conclusion: 

Shoe insoles can work incredibly well for anyone struggling with foot or ankle issues. Whether they are in just your work shoes or in your training shoes as well, they can help to decrease a lot of pain issues that could lead to injury.

These pain issues could also travel from your feet up to your knees and hips if not taken care of before it spreads.

Both the Superfeet Black and the Superfeet Carbon athletic shoe insoles can be great options for you that will help prevent injury and prevent or decrease pain that being on your feet without supportive shoe insoles can cause for a great price. 


Last update on 2020-02-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API