Protalus vs Superfeet Insoles - Which Are Better and Why_

Protalus vs Superfeet Insoles - Which Are Better and Why?

Are you planning on buying new insoles? If the answer is yes, you need a reliable and top-quality product, which means you should go with a premium brand.

You may have gotten it down to two names, but you can't decide the winner of the Protalus vs Superfeet showdown. We did thorough research on both, and here is what we discovered!


Why Should You Wear Insoles?

Have you ever wondered about the benefits of wearing insoles? If you are considering them, the chances are you are having problems with pain or discomfort while walking or running.

Insoles are designed to reduce stress on your feet, especially if you are spending a long time standing during the day.

You can find models that are perfect for everyday use, but there are also specialized insoles suitable for runners and other athletes.

If you spend hours per day standing, or you like to lead an active lifestyle, you want to wear insoles to avoid any issues with foot or back pain.

Even if you are only feeling a mild discomfort at the moment, you should act in time before the situation gets worse.

If you believe the issues with the pain are critical for any reason, you should consult a specialist as soon as possible.


How to Choose the Best Insoles for Your Feet

Before you decide on the insoles you want to buy you probably want to know more about the things that you should consider when choosing the insoles.

Take a look at the several factors you should consider below.

Superfeet GREEN Insoles, Professional-Grade High Arch Orthotic Insert for Maximum Support, Unisex, Green, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens

Sizing

The first thing you want to ensure is that you pick the insoles of the right size.

Both Protalus and Superfeet include a size chart with their products, and you shouldn’t have a problem picking a suitable size.

However, if you are in a dilemma, always go with the bigger one. You can always trim the insoles to fit your shoe and foot, but there is no way to expand them.

Volume

You may encounter product descriptions mentioning the high or low volume of the insole.

It doesn't describe how loud it is, but how much space it takes in your shoe.

If you have room to accommodate a high-volume shoe, go for it. But if you feel like the space for the insole is limited, be careful with your choice.

Superfeet ORANGE Insoles, High Arch Support and Forefoot Cushion Orthotic Insole for Anti-fatigue, Unisex, Orange, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens

Profile

A low profile usually describes an insole that you don’t feel that much at the bottom of your foot.

Some would even say this describes the thickness of the insole since low profile insoles are usually thin.

Comfort

All the above-mentioned factors are mere information to help you, but comfort is the crucial thing to consider when choosing insoles

You want to consider your arch first because insoles used for a high arch are different than those used for flat feet.

Superfeet Run Comfort Insoles Carbon Fiber Running Shoe Orthotic Inserts for Support and Cushion, X-Large/F: 12.5+ US Womens / 11.5-13 US Mens


The material will also play a role, but you can’t go wrong with memory foam, gel, or wrap knit polyester.

You should also stick to premium brands and manufacturers, and avoid risking your discomfort worsening with unknown brands and products.


Superfeet COPPER, Memory Foam Comfort plus Support Anti-fatigue Replacement Insoles, Unisex, Copper, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet Run Comfort Insoles Carbon Fiber Running Shoe Orthotic Inserts for Support and Cushion, Large/E: 10.5-12 US Womens / 9.5-11 US Mens
M100 - Max Alignment, Replaces Stock Insole, Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for max Support, Alignment and Comfort.
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
M75-3/4 Size Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for Maximum Support, Alignment, and Comfort. Sits on top existing Insoles.
Superfeet COPPER, Memory Foam Comfort plus Support Anti-fatigue Replacement Insoles, Unisex, Copper, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet Run Comfort Insoles Carbon Fiber Running Shoe Orthotic Inserts for Support and Cushion, Large/E: 10.5-12 US Womens / 9.5-11 US Mens
M100 - Max Alignment, Replaces Stock Insole, Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for max Support, Alignment and Comfort.
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
M75-3/4 Size Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for Maximum Support, Alignment, and Comfort. Sits on top existing Insoles.
Prime
-
Rating
Reviews
753 Reviews
32 Reviews
141 Reviews
452 Reviews
16 Reviews
Price
$54.95
$49.95
$99.89
$54.95
$99.95
Superfeet COPPER, Memory Foam Comfort plus Support Anti-fatigue Replacement Insoles, Unisex, Copper, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet COPPER, Memory Foam Comfort plus Support Anti-fatigue Replacement Insoles, Unisex, Copper, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Prime
Rating
Reviews
753 Reviews
Price
$54.95
Superfeet Run Comfort Insoles Carbon Fiber Running Shoe Orthotic Inserts for Support and Cushion, Large/E: 10.5-12 US Womens / 9.5-11 US Mens
Superfeet Run Comfort Insoles Carbon Fiber Running Shoe Orthotic Inserts for Support and Cushion, Large/E: 10.5-12 US Womens / 9.5-11 US Mens
Prime
Rating
Reviews
32 Reviews
Price
$49.95
M100 - Max Alignment, Replaces Stock Insole, Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for max Support, Alignment and Comfort.
M100 - Max Alignment, Replaces Stock Insole, Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for max Support, Alignment and Comfort.
Prime
Rating
Reviews
141 Reviews
Price
$99.89
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Prime
Rating
Reviews
452 Reviews
Price
$54.95
M75-3/4 Size Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for Maximum Support, Alignment, and Comfort. Sits on top existing Insoles.
M75-3/4 Size Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for Maximum Support, Alignment, and Comfort. Sits on top existing Insoles.
Prime
-
Rating
Reviews
16 Reviews
Price
$99.95

Protalus vs Superfeet Insoles with Reviews

We detail the five most popular lines of these insoles and share why you should chose one over the other. 

Superfeet Copper Insoles

These copper insoles are unisex, which means both men and women can wear them. They come in several different sizes, and it shouldn’t be a problem to pick a suitable one.

Superfeet designed insoles completely out of memory foam with a synthetic sole. The insoles are a low profile, which means you shouldn’t feel them that much below your feet.

Superfeet ORANGE Insoles, High Arch Support and Forefoot Cushion Orthotic Insole for Anti-fatigue, Unisex, Orange, X-Large/F: 12.5+ Wmns/11.5-13 Mens

You can use the insoles for long-distance walks and high-impact activities like running. The deep heel cup will make these activities more manageable.

However, the company describes them as high-volume insoles. While some users may like that, others may find them too bulky.

Although they are not among the most affordable insoles out there, Superfeet seems to have used durable memory foam, which should contribute to longevity.

Pros

  • ​Made completely out of memory foam
  • ​Suitable for high-impact activities like running
  • ​Available in several sizes
  • ​Low-profile insoles

Cons

  • ​Some users may find them too bulky
  • ​A bit pricey
Superfeet COPPER, Memory Foam Comfort plus Support Anti-fatigue Replacement Insoles, Unisex, Copper, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
753 Reviews
Superfeet COPPER, Memory Foam Comfort plus Support Anti-fatigue Replacement Insoles, Unisex, Copper, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
  • FIT PROFILE: High volume / Low profile (Volume refers to the amount of space the insole will take up in your shoe. Profile is how much shape you can expect to feel under your foot)
  • REINFORCED STABILIZER CAP: the base of the insole that supports the rearfoot and provides structure and stability to the foam layer
  • DEEP HEEL CUP: features a deep, narrow heel cup that helps support the foot during high-impact activities and long distances

​Superfeet Run Comfort

The primary goal Superfeet have when designing these insoles was to deliver a great solution for runners. However, there is no reason why you shouldn’t use them for walking, too.

The insoles are high-volume, which means you need to secure enough room for them in your shoes.

Superfeet Run Comfort Insoles Carbon Fiber Running Shoe Orthotic Inserts for Support and Cushion, Large/E: 10.5-12 US Womens / 9.5-11 US Mens

The company pinpoints that users with medium to high arch will probably find them the insoles the most comfortable.

The construction seems durable, and the manufacturer claims the insoles should last for 500 miles or 12 months. However, they do offer only a 60-day warranty for defects.

Thanks to several available sizes, both men and women can find a fitting option that suits them.

The stabilizer cap and the deep heel cup provide added support and structure. The insoles also offer odor control that should serve you as long as the product itself.

Pros

  • ​Designed for both running and walking
  • ​Deep heel cup provides extra structure and support
  • ​Durable odor control
  • ​Suitable for both men and women

Cons

  • ​It may not be the best fit if your arch is not medium or high
  • ​The company only provides a 60-day warranty
Sale
Superfeet Run Comfort Insoles Carbon Fiber Running Shoe Orthotic Inserts for Support and Cushion, Large/E: 10.5-12 US Womens / 9.5-11 US Mens
32 Reviews
Superfeet Run Comfort Insoles Carbon Fiber Running Shoe Orthotic Inserts for Support and Cushion, Large/E: 10.5-12 US Womens / 9.5-11 US Mens
  • DESIGNED FOR: Superfeet RUN Comfort Insoles are ideal for running or walking, helping reduce foot fatigue while gaining efficiency.
  • RECOMMENDED SHOE TYPE: RUN Comfort Insoles are a high volume design providing MAX support and ideal in running, walking or everyday shoes that have a little extra room to accommodate the volume of the insoles.
  • WHAT TYPE OF FOOT: Ideal for those with a medium to high arch looking for maximum arch support.

​Protalus M100 Insoles

We went through and did a very in-depth review of the Protalus insole brand. You can find the review here

These are the first insoles designed by Protalus that found their spot in our list. The company pinpoints how M series is their flagship series.

The insoles utilize the tri-planar technology that aims to provide optimal shock absorption, control, and comfort.

M100 - Max Alignment, Replaces Stock Insole

Thanks to that, the product may assist in decreasing stress on your feet while walking or running. That can help to reduce both discomfort and pain.

The size chart should make choosing the right insoles a piece of cake.

The product is suitable for high-impact activities, such as running and basketball. It is, however, a bit pricey, especially if you keep in mind that it might not be as durable as you expect.

If you are too rough on the insoles, they may wear out quickly.

Pros

  • ​It may help to reduce pain and discomfort while on your feet
  • ​Tri-planar technology for comfort, control, and shock absorption
  • ​Suitable for athletes and high-impact activities
  • ​Numerous sizes available

Cons

  • ​A bit expensive
  • ​Not as durable as you might expect
Sale
M100 - Max Alignment, Replaces Stock Insole, Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for max Support, Alignment and Comfort.
141 Reviews
M100 - Max Alignment, Replaces Stock Insole, Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for max Support, Alignment and Comfort.
  • Great for people on their feet all day
  • Designed for boots, shoes, and athletic shoes
  • Max Support

​Superfeet Carbon Insoles

The last in the line of Superfeet's insoles we are reviewing is their thinnest insole currently available.

That very thing makes them specific – you may find them extremely comfortable, especially if you have a high arch or tight shoes. On the other hand, some users find them too hard.

Superfeet, CARBON Pro Hockey, Carbon Fiber Professional Performance Hockey Skate Insoles, Unisex, Blaze Yellow, Large E: Skate 9-10, US

The manufacturer used wrap knit polyester but added carbon fiber and polymer blend in the stabilizer cap.

Thanks to that, you can rest assured the insoles will provide optimal structure and support.

While you probably won't feel the insoles in your shoes, you might hear them while walking and running because they might make squeaking noises.

Pros

  • ​They can help to reduce stress while walking or running
  • ​Thin insoles that don’t take a lot of room
  • ​Stabilizer cap ensures optimal support and structure
  • ​Suitable for tight shoes

Cons

  • ​May be a bit too hard for some users
  • ​You may hear squeaking noises from the insoles
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
452 Reviews
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
  • FIT PROFILE: Low volume / Low profile (Volume refers to the amount of space the insole will take up in your shoe. Profile is how much shape you can expect to feel under your foot)
  • CARBON FIBER STABILIZER CAP: the stabilizer cap is reinforced with EVOLYTE, a proprietary carbon fiber & polymer blend, to provide structure and support
  • LOW-PROFILE DESIGN: the thinnest Superfeet insole

Protalus M75

These insoles also belong to the M series designed by this manufacturer. The difference is that you can use this product on shoes that have cemented or sewn-in insoles.

The item is low-volume and provides adequate support and comfort.

M75-3/4 Size, Max Alignment, fits on top of existing Insole

​The heel cup is curved and conforming, which should minimize the stress during long hours of walking or playing your favorite sport.

The insoles don't take a lot of room, and they can help to reduce the discomfort you may feel. Thanks to the vast choice of sizes, men, women, and children can all choose the one that suits them.

However, keep in mind that M75 might be a bit expensive. Considering the money, the durability could be better, too, but it seems that they can help to handle spending many hours a day on your feet.

Pros

  • ​Suitable for shoes with cemented insoles
  • ​Low-volume insoles that don’t take a lot of room
  • ​Heel cup helps to reduce stress on your feet
  • ​Available in sizes for men, women, and children

Cons

  • ​A bit expensive
  • ​The overall durability could be better
M75-3/4 Size Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for Maximum Support, Alignment, and Comfort. Sits on top existing Insoles.
16 Reviews
M75-3/4 Size Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for Maximum Support, Alignment, and Comfort. Sits on top existing Insoles.
  • Great for people on their feet all day
  • Insole sits on top of existing shoe insole
  • Support

Superfeet COPPER, Memory Foam Comfort plus Support Anti-fatigue Replacement Insoles, Unisex, Copper, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet Run Comfort Insoles Carbon Fiber Running Shoe Orthotic Inserts for Support and Cushion, Large/E: 10.5-12 US Womens / 9.5-11 US Mens
M100 - Max Alignment, Replaces Stock Insole, Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for max Support, Alignment and Comfort.
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
M75-3/4 Size Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for Maximum Support, Alignment, and Comfort. Sits on top existing Insoles.
Superfeet COPPER, Memory Foam Comfort plus Support Anti-fatigue Replacement Insoles, Unisex, Copper, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet Run Comfort Insoles Carbon Fiber Running Shoe Orthotic Inserts for Support and Cushion, Large/E: 10.5-12 US Womens / 9.5-11 US Mens
M100 - Max Alignment, Replaces Stock Insole, Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for max Support, Alignment and Comfort.
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
M75-3/4 Size Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for Maximum Support, Alignment, and Comfort. Sits on top existing Insoles.
Prime
-
Rating
Reviews
753 Reviews
32 Reviews
141 Reviews
452 Reviews
16 Reviews
Price
$54.95
$49.95
$99.89
$54.95
$99.95
Superfeet COPPER, Memory Foam Comfort plus Support Anti-fatigue Replacement Insoles, Unisex, Copper, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet COPPER, Memory Foam Comfort plus Support Anti-fatigue Replacement Insoles, Unisex, Copper, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Prime
Rating
Reviews
753 Reviews
Price
$54.95
Superfeet Run Comfort Insoles Carbon Fiber Running Shoe Orthotic Inserts for Support and Cushion, Large/E: 10.5-12 US Womens / 9.5-11 US Mens
Superfeet Run Comfort Insoles Carbon Fiber Running Shoe Orthotic Inserts for Support and Cushion, Large/E: 10.5-12 US Womens / 9.5-11 US Mens
Prime
Rating
Reviews
32 Reviews
Price
$49.95
M100 - Max Alignment, Replaces Stock Insole, Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for max Support, Alignment and Comfort.
M100 - Max Alignment, Replaces Stock Insole, Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for max Support, Alignment and Comfort.
Prime
Rating
Reviews
141 Reviews
Price
$99.89
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Superfeet CARBON, Thin and Strong Insoles for Pain Relief in Performance Athletic and Tight Casual Shoes, Unisex, Gray, Large/E: 10.5-12 Wmns/9.5-11 Mens
Prime
Rating
Reviews
452 Reviews
Price
$54.95
M75-3/4 Size Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for Maximum Support, Alignment, and Comfort. Sits on top existing Insoles.
M75-3/4 Size Insoles for Men and Women Shoe Inserts for Maximum Support, Alignment, and Comfort. Sits on top existing Insoles.
Prime
-
Rating
Reviews
16 Reviews
Price
$99.95

Conclusion: Protalus vs Superfeet battle

In the Protalus versus Superfeet battle, we would have to say that Superfeet is the clear winner.

These are both premium manufacturers, but if you compare them directly, it seems that they deliver better solutions for the users than Protalus.

You can't go wrong with choosing Superfeet Copper insoles. They are suitable for everyday use and high-impact activities, such as running and sports.

The insoles also do not take a lot of room in your shoes to ensure optimal comfort. Ultimately, feel free to check out other reviews, too. 

Use our buying guide to consider your preferences and pick the insoles that are the best fit for you!

Last update on 2019-09-18 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API